Conquering NYC One Meal at a Time

Posts tagged “Penelope

Review: Penelope Brunch

This morning we went to Penelope for a nice little Saturday brunch. Typically we can’t get our acts together for brunch until somewhere around 1130-1pm.  After an early 9am wake up time we headed to Penelope around 1040am.  When we got there we told it would be a 45 minute wait.  Their estimates were about accurate and we sat down at 11:30pm.

The price fixe brunch selection was fairly limited about 8-10 choices Including Nutella French Toast, Spinach Pie, a build your own omelet option and pumpkin waffle. I decided on the BBLT (double bacon BLT) with the addition of an egg over easy.  My friend went with the Stuffed Nutella French Toast.

BBLT Brunch @ Penelope

BBLT Sandwich & Fresh Cut French Fries

The BBLT was more like a regular BLT I didn’t notice any extra bacon.  It came with a black pepper mayo and fresh cut skin on French fries.  The sandwich was on toasted thick cut sourdough bread.  Definitely an enjoyable sandwich and I was a fan of the added egg & bread choice but I don’t know that it was worth the 45 minute wait.  The French fries had good flavor but I prefer a crispy fry and these were a little soggy.

The Nutella French Toast on the other hand was phenomenal.  I don’t like sweets so I’m not sure I would be able to finish an entire order but the bite I had was melt in your mouth delicious.  The French toast is served with a generous portion of fresh fruit (blueberries and strawberries).

We ordered sake bloody marys which were good and made with fresh horse radish (my preference).  I didn’t notice a difference between this bloody and regular vodka BMs.

Sake Bloody Mary

Sake Bloody Mary

What to expect:

A fairly limited price fix brunch menu

Long wait times

Alternative brunch cocktails (apple cider mimosa, sake Bloody Marys)

Spending about $20/person

Pleasant Waiters & Good service (I liked that we weren’t rushed while trying to decide what to order).

A very well written menu (everything sounds delicious)

Overall Rating: 3.5/5 stars

(I docked overall rating by .5 stars for long wait times)

What are your favorite weekend brunch spots? Let me know in the comments.

--DBlock